This is an article I wrote for the Garden Railway Club
newsletter in May, 2007. I hope you find it useful.
Just a little background before I get to the nitty gritty.
I've only been in the wondrous Garden Railway world since 2000 but I've
kicked around at all sorts of things that have required the use of a
soldering iron or soldering gun. While I'm no expert, I've gained some
useful practical knowledge in making things connect, electrically, and work
well, while avoiding the dreaded cold-solder joint. More on that later.
Most of my efforts to join pieces of metal together using
solder have involved small wires and finicky electronic parts that don't
like too much heat, but working on bigger pieces of metal is quite
different, though the principles are the same.
If you use track power for your garden railway, one of the
many challenges is to keep power flowing to all parts of the track when you
want it. It's frustrating to get a train into a long block-section only to
find it's not getting any power because of bad rail joints that are not
transferring the power properly.
Skeena Pacific Railway is track-powered. But (finally) it
suffers very few track power problems due to bad electrical joints. Over the
time that the track has been down, I've tried several methods to maintain
continuity of power across rail joins. Someone suggested running additional
wires along the track and connecting them at intervals to keep the power up.
To me, this seemed unnecessary when there were already two, large pieces of
brass already there to conduct the power. It must be just a matter of making
the joints conduct electricity better. I used electrically-conductive grease
on the railjoiners. When that wasn't satisfactory, I tried soldering the
joints together. Limited success was achieved but my 260 watt Weller
soldering gun just couldn't put enough heat into the rails to get a good
join, resulting in... tada.. the dreaded cold-solder joint. It looks like it
has worked, but it hasn't.
That's when I started using a propane torch. Lots of heat.
WAY TOOO MUCH heat. Wrecked the plastic ties, made a mess. Right idea but
the wrong tool.
An explanation for those who want it. To make a good solder
joint, one that electricity will like, requires having a good, tight
physical joint. The pieces have to fit snugly together. You also need to
have both of the pieces being joined:
Clean - use a small wire brush, the type you can get from most hardware
stores that are used for cleaning small pieces.
Prepared - use solder paste on both pieces. I don't recommend
using 'acid' based paste such as that used in plumbing as it may eventually
rot rail joiners. You can get resin-based paste and solder, such as is used
in electronics, from Radio Shack, or whatever it's called, or a neat
little store in Langley.
Hot - this is the tricky part. Both pieces need to be hot enough to
allow the solder to melt properly, 'flow', and adhere to both pieces to make
the join. Without these, you will not have a successful solder joint.
So after the propane-torch episode, I decided I needed a
'resistance-solder' rig. Without too much detail, this electrically charges
each piece of metal so they both get hot. I looked around and found that
'American Beauty' http:
//www.americanbeautytools.com/ had such an item, but it is (for my
pocketbook) very expensive. If you are making brass models and such, it's a
wonderful tool, but.....$$$. I found an article on how to make your own
resistance soldering rig, but I'm too lazy, uh, busy.
So, why not, I said to myself, use my 260 watt Weller gun as
a resistance solderer. What the gun does is put low-voltage electricity into
two sides that meet at a tip. Squeeze the trigger, power goes to the tip,
the tip gets hot. What if I cut the tip, and put one electrode (tip-piece)
on each side of the metal pieces to be joined? The pieces to be joined would
become the 'tip' get hot and... voila... a good solder joint. You do have to
have a little patience, this method does take a little time to get the
necessary heat into the rail-joiner and the rail itself, but it does the
job. No melted ties. No damage to the track.